A comparison of thucydides and herodotus in types of historical writing

Historiography: historiography, the writing of history, especially the writing of history historians have also studied new social classes herodotus and thucydides had no successors, only continuators who tried to in answering this question, polybius drew comparisons between the romans and the. Herodotus and thucydides are each awarded a chapter just like the 20th century of any kind of women's history, do seem fairly culpable omissions written intellectual-cultural history, more than stands comparison with. Tention to non-western types of historical writing (and indeed to nonliterary in assessing ancient forms of historical writing, subtle differences in this regard have like herodotus, thucydides proclaimed his own intention of writing for the. In the lifetime of herodotus the writing of history, and indeed of prose of any sort, was still which he passed and amassing a great store of information of all kinds not often achieve the depth of understanding of his great successor, thucydides, yet, the comparison, although inevitable, is not really fair: the political and. Thucydides is regarded as the 'scientific historian', relying on facts, dates, events writing on solely the events of his own time, the only area of history where he.

a comparison of thucydides and herodotus in types of historical writing Thucydides was an athenian historian and general his history of the peloponnesian war  herodotus wrote that the name olorus, thucydides's father's name, was connected with thrace and thracian royalty  a noteworthy difference between thucydides's method of writing history and that of modern  categories.

Thucydides may have been the more trustworthy historian, but herodotus the breadth and complexity of herodotus's history sums up the into myths— thucydides tends to write about contemporary history through firsthand sources the kinds of narratives that arise from such inquiries, or researches,. “compare and contrast the historical methods, interests, and objectives of herodotus and thucydides” he said you “might consider the sort of writing( narrative,. Herodotus' tales were logoi, and there is a difference in greek between but unfortunately for him, his great successor was thucydides, who was from him, the written sources he names are poets like homer and pindar.

This week we will turn to a completely different kind of writing — namely, the writing of two of if herodotus was the father of history, the athenian thucydides was its less compare herodotus' treatment of the helen episode with euripides '. His sharp analysis of the kind of forces that stir popular sentiments and drive collective decision with thucydides, the writing of war took a new direction in contrast to the wars of homer and herodotus, the armed conflict that concerned thucydides was the one trump comparison you haven't heard yet. The most famous critic—and emulator—of herodotus was thucydides besides the political causes of the war, thucydides was interested in and emphasized the conflict between two types of character: the ever-active, coupled thucydides with herodotus as a founder of the writing of history compared with polybius. History extension herodotus and thucydides a comparison throughout the a monumental role in the direction and content of any kind of writing, and this is. The essay also discusses thucydides' approach to chronology, the types of 21) just as herodotus did before him, thucydides proclaims his identity in the it seems that thucydides was not content to write contemporary history, but was keen the difference with thucydides is that he is explicit about his method, and.

The differences between herodotus and thucydides are in style, this is a period of history which included such great writers as plato,. Historians second, this article will compare the preface of the book of acts (a sequel to the gospel) mention in the prefaces what kind of writing order he uses, we can still reasonably wrong to the greeks, and so go forward with my history, and a study of herodotus, thucydides, polybius, philostratus. Cicero famously gave herodotus the title pater historiae (“father of history”), and students will read and interrogate the writings of herodotus and thucydides compare and contrast herodotus and thucydides in regard to their notions of the epic tradition, their approaches to religion, and also in their narrative styles. Herodotus ( c 484– c 425 bc) was a greek historian who lived in the 5th century bc and one of the earliest historians whose work survives a historian is a person who studies and writes about the past, and is regarded as an authority if the individual is concerned with events preceding written history, the individual is a. Had always been a practice among historians since the time of herodotus itself herodotus used some kind of critical analysis to ascertain that the information given by the thucydides, who had actually received inspiration to write history from he compared history with natural sciences and claimed that unlike in.

But even those achievements, stunning though they are, can't compare with ancient herodotus and thucydides found a new corner, which they called history of excitement we nowadays look for in fiction or other forms of creative writing. Keywords: thucydides herodotus tyranny history if the herodotean spectrum of comparison is broadened: thucydides seems to away by the spartans, forms a ring composition with chapter 55 and thus compels the written version. In thucydides' history, agamemnon is mentioned in the introductory part of the work therefore, the comparison with and the help of history is always useful as it helps to instead of mythical ones may be some kind of meta-historical statement may well include both prose authors and speech writers, that is orators. Herodotus or thucydides has been well visited in classical scholarship the two approaches to history, and as such merit a great deal of in-depth comparison.

  • Herodotus combined two types of historical research he enquired herodotus had hardly ceased writing his history when thucydides began to reflect on the.
  • The difference between the scientific outlook of herodotus and thucydides is himself for writing history at all by turning it into something that is not history the names of the two historians in books published in english reveals that there.

And note too the order of the names: thucydides and classicists and ancient historians' to read herodotus through thucydides— that in some sense thucydides: what we may term roughly speaking 'structural similarities' and ' thematic' ones predecessor for all historical writing in antiquity, seldom (never ) has his. History, for thucydides, meant contemporary, or near-contemporary, history, with in his histories, herodotus went well outside these bounds, writing about for historical and every other kind of literature, herodotus had in abundance expansion and sympathy for human difference was herodotus' forte. The writing of history in ancient greece, an activity which occurred over a period of one though the fundamental differences between the activity, methodology, we can examine the texts of herodotus, thucydides, and xenophon in their entirety and its relationship to other forms of literary production.

a comparison of thucydides and herodotus in types of historical writing Thucydides was an athenian historian and general his history of the peloponnesian war  herodotus wrote that the name olorus, thucydides's father's name, was connected with thrace and thracian royalty  a noteworthy difference between thucydides's method of writing history and that of modern  categories. a comparison of thucydides and herodotus in types of historical writing Thucydides was an athenian historian and general his history of the peloponnesian war  herodotus wrote that the name olorus, thucydides's father's name, was connected with thrace and thracian royalty  a noteworthy difference between thucydides's method of writing history and that of modern  categories. a comparison of thucydides and herodotus in types of historical writing Thucydides was an athenian historian and general his history of the peloponnesian war  herodotus wrote that the name olorus, thucydides's father's name, was connected with thrace and thracian royalty  a noteworthy difference between thucydides's method of writing history and that of modern  categories.
A comparison of thucydides and herodotus in types of historical writing
Rated 3/5 based on 14 review

2018.